top of page

Orange Creamsicle Loaf Cake

Truth be told, I can be a lazy gal, so I often toss all the wet ingredients into my blender, however, these directions are for mixing bowls and this works great too. You'll love this moist cake!


It's best to use a kitchen scale whenever possible. If you don't yet own a scale, these recipes are based upon 'lightly packed' measuring cups, so whether you use the 'dip and sweep' method of measuring or the 'spooning into the cup' method, always gently press down on the mix in the measuring cup and add more to fill the cup, as necessary. 

1 C Mix weighs approx. 125g.


1. To bring eggs to room temperature quickly, set them in a glass of very warm water.

2. Melted butter should be warm not hot when adding to a recipe.

3. I like to sift the Bakery Mix when making cakes.

4. Metal pans brown and crisp more than glass pans.

5. Glass pans take longer to come to temperature.

6. Ovens vary, so bake times may need to be adjusted.

7. Use room temperature ingredients for this recipe.

8.The more yellow your egg yolks are the more color the cake will have, so use free range eggs!

Makes 1 8.5 x 4.5 Loaf



1 1/4 C S'WEEET! Sweetener Blend (175g)

2 t Baking Powder 


5 Eggs - (250g)

2/3 C Orange Juice (180g)

6 T Melted Butter (84g)

2 T Orange Zest

1 t Orange Extract (or culinary oil - optional)

1 t Vanilla Extract

1 t Almond Extract


1. Pre-heat your oven to 350°F and grease/line a loaf pan.

2. Sift the Bakery Mix into a bowl and whisk in the sweetener and baking powder. Set aside.

3. In a large bowl, combine the eggs, milk, melted butter, vinegar and extracts .

4. Whisk the dry mixture in with the liquids until well combined.

5. Let the batter rest a few minutes, then whisk again

6. Pour batter into pan and bake 60-65 minutes or until a toothpick comes out mostly clean.


Stir together

1 C S'WEEET! Sweetener Blend (140g)

1 T Orange Juice

1 T Heavy Cream

Pour over the cake once it has completely cooled.

SWEETENERS VARY tremendously and will affect the outcome of all baked goods.

We suggest using our new sweetener blend, S'WEEET!, real sugar, or a substitute such as Lakanto's Baking Blend, or Mrs. Jones blend (which contains sugar). If you prefer to bake with a liquid sweetener, you will likely need to add a 1-2 T more Bakery Mix. Allulose and kabocha-based sweeteners (Bocha Sweet) will make baked goods very soft and not crispy. Erythritol can make them firm and more crumbly.

To print this recipe look for 'printer' button in the social bar below.


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page